Please consider signing Letter of Protest to India's Ministry of Human Resource Development, regarding their Notice to Professor Yogendra Yadav of the University Grants Council
I have received the following plea from a trustworthy fellow-academic. I am not aware of all the details of the case, but the details given below have satisfied me sufficiently to prompt me to sign the letter. I would request you to consider doing the same - if you wish to do so, please send an email to Shri Prashant Bhushan on firstname.lastname@example.org OR to Prof. Anand Kumar at email@example.com
Here is the text of the letter of protest:
Dr. M. Mangapati Pallam Raju,
Minister of Human Resource Development,
Government of India.
Dear Dr. Raju,
The news of the Ministry of Human Resource Development serving a show-cause
notice to Prof. Yogendra Yadav, Member, UGC, to explain why he should not be removed
from the UGC has shocked and dismayed the academic community. The notice mentions
a conflict of interest, Prof. Yogendra Yadav being an active member of a newly registered
political party, as the reason for such removal.
The UGC has a formal policy on Conflict of Interest and Code of Conduct for
Members of the Commission which does not mention political activity as a potential
conflict of interest. The University Grants Commission (Disqualification, Retirement and
Conditions of Service) Rule, 1992 provides for specific grounds of disqualification
which, again, does not include membership of a political party as a valid ground.
It is evident that the decision of serving the show-cause notice stems from the fact
that Prof. Yogendra Yadav chose to be an active member of the Commission who raised
questions and recorded his objections in regard to several matters of national importance
such as the introduction of the four year undergraduate programme in Delhi University,
bypassing of the recommendations of the UGC committee in the notification of the API
scheme, closing down of Centres for Social Inclusion and Exclusion, and the decision to
set up a Centre on Teacher Education in a Technical University that does not even have a
department of education. Prof. Yogendra Yadav’s persistent efforts to point out
irregularities in the conduct of Commission meetings and recording of minutes also
seems to have put some officials in an uncomfortable situation.
We believe that such active concern is precisely what should be expected from a
member of a body of national importance like the UGC as this is what strengthens the
working of such bodies. We are shocked that the Ministry, which, in a healthy democracy,
should have given due importance to the matters raised, and should have encouraged such
vigilant participation, has instead initiated the process of removing the member. Such a
measure sends a strong message of intolerance towards all members who consider it their
duty to express their opinions and threatens to severely erode the ethos of informed
debate and fearless participation. It demonstrates an utter disregard for the autonomy
vested in the institution of the UGC without which it cannot be expected to play its role
as a regulatory body effectively.
We, the undersigned, therefore urge you to take immediate steps to withdraw the
show-cause notice issued to Prof. Yogendra Yadav.