Friday, 4 March 2011

The current situation of Dalits in India

Following my speech at the Dalit Freedom Network in Germany a few days ago, a gentleman approached me with the following request: "If you find the time to send me a few of your thoughts on business and human rights regarding the Dalits for that upcomig hearing at the Bundestag in Berlin I would very much appreciate that."

My response:

As you know, the Dalits (formerly correctly known as "Untouchables") with the "Other Backward Castes" are the majority of the Indian population.

The word "Dalit" means "crushed" or "Crushed into a mass".

As untouchability was outlawed under the Constitution of the Republic of India, when that Constitution was adopted in 1951, and as a policy was put in place of reserving a few seats for Dalits in government schools, hospitals, bureaucratic jobs, and so on, the fortunes of some Dalits improved - to the point that there is now a so-caled "creamy layer" among Dalits. The existence of this "creamy layer" along with the existence of what one may call a "dry layer" among other castes, makes many Indians think that the problem of untouchability and caste-discrimination has been resolved and that nothing further needs to be done - in fact, many are seeking even to abolish the reservations that exist for Dalits. There is also the complication that non-Untouchables have got them classified as "Dalits" in order to benefit from the reservations! However, the "creamy layer" among the Dalits is extremely thin, and the vast majority of Dalits continue to face discrimination against them in social life as well as in employment opportunities. In fact, the reservations offer, in many cases, only a theoretical benefit, as many government schools exist even today only on paper!

The Census now being carried out in India is the first one since the 1930s because, for various reasons, no one wanted to find out the current number of Dalits and people belonging to various religious and economic backgrounds.

When the current Census is completed later this year, we will be in a position to know something like the facts about the current situation.

However, what is clear is that the policy of abolishing untouchability and offering reservations based on caste has been a mixed success - and that, so far, the majority of Dalits continue to be the majority of those who have benefited least from India's development since the country became independent.

Much more needs to be done to ensure that the Dalits progress. Fully one-third of India lives on less than US Dollars 1.25 a day. Another one-third of India's population lives on more than US Dollars 1.25 but less than US Dollars 2.50 a day. The majority of Dalits fall into these two categories.

Some time ago, the Government of India commented to private companies that, in a liberalising economy, private companies needed to do much more than they were doing to employ Dalits, and that if private companies did not improve their record, then the government would consider requiring private companies by law to reserve a proportion of positions for Dalits. Companies have done something but, like the government itself, too little so far - and it is not clear whether the current administration has the ability or the determination to do more on that front.

Meanwhile,as I said, the picture is complicated because for example there are now many poor families from other castes - of course, they should also be helped to stand again on their own feet.

On the other hand, SOME Dalits have made significant or even substantial economic progress. That progress is used as an excuse by the educated classes not to exert oneself greatly in relation to these problems (with a handful of exceptions, of course).

My conclusion is that the problems that Dalits face have become invisible to educated Indians - but are glaringly obvious to any interested observer of the country.

ENDS

Sunday, 20 February 2011

Four kinds of Indians - or, Is there any POLITICAL hope for our country?

I was kicked out of India by Mrs Indira Gandhi’s government because I was not prepared to sit quietly and watch the country’s institutions being subverted during
the Emergency.

Not that I did a lot, or even anything much. I only raised my voice. And, as I was merely 25 at the time, the system could afford to ignore me - and did ignore me as
long as there were (lots! thousands! tens of thousands!) of more important people.

Eventually, however, the system caught up with me. I was given the choice of
joining the Party or leaving the country.

I was lucky. Many tens of thousands were locked up – and how many were simply eliminated we still do not know.

Much later, I gathered that about 200 young people had been given the choice between
exile and the Party, as they were considered “too intelligent to kill”. I have no idea whether that figure is correct. It could have been 20 or 200,000....

Where the others went, I have no idea. But I am aware of at least one other person in Europe who was then young, and who is now I guess around 60 years old.

After Mrs Indira Gandhi abandoned the stupidities of the Emergency and returned the country to democracy, it became possible for me too to return, and I have done so more or less often. However, most of my visits have lasted, for various reasons, only about a week.

Having been in India for about a month now, and having spent time in Mumbai, Goa and the National Capital Region, I am coming to the conclusion that we have four kinds of Indians.

A few – a very few - are like Trees. By which I mean that they are rooted in the soil, and they not only produce enough to sustain themselves, they are actually productive enough to provide for others: shade and flowers and fruit. They beautify
the landscape and contribute to the country in every way.

However, these Trees may or may not attract notice. Most of the people who come to the headlines and attract public attention are like Jackals – sniffing around for the best way of exploiting or attacking the living and the dead, in order to
take as much from the country as possible.

Then we have the Parasites: concerned with making as little effort as possible but living off the system. This includes not only smaller businesspeople, but all those who focus on collecting “unofficial taxes”. That’s most (or at least many) of our bureaucrats, police, teachers, doctors...

Finally, we have the Window Watchers – who constitute the majority in our country. They can see what is going on, but can’t or won’t (or, in any case, don’t) exert
themselves to change anything. That includes not only our ordinary citizens, but also most of our professionals – who should certainly be in a position to exert some leverage

In this discouraging and dry landscape, I have finally come across a ray of hope: India’s first political party founded on ethical principles. Called the Adarsha
Rashtra Vikas Party (ideal nation development party, or ARVP), it was founded in Autumn 2009 and is based in Lucknow.

What makes the party different from all the others that we have had since Independence is its commitment to ethics, equality, human rights and development (all necessary for an “ideal” nation).

Of course, every party pays lip service to such values, so what’s different about the ARVP?

Well, it does not allow people to have any level of leadership unless they undertake “ethical training” at their own expense each month.

Naturally, in light of the cleverness of our people and the deviousness of our culture, and in light of the fact that the party is in its infancy, it needs to put
lots of things in place in order to be both successful in ethics and successful in politics.

The founder, Mohan Philip, is confident that ARVP will be successful because the country is now completely fed up with the sort of unethical politics which has been practiced.

Asked why had other ethically-oriented parties, such as the Professionals Party, failed at the last general election, he answered, “Because they did nothing at the grass roots”.

What the ARVP is doing at the grass roots is truly remarkable, as it builds up a cadre of people committed to ethical action.

Once they decided to form the party, they sought people who would specifically connect with their vision. They selected 10 committed individuals and designed a pictorial vision document for them to clearly explain the vision to recruit other
potential leaders. Out of groups of 30 potential candidates who responded, two day meetings were held in Lucknow where the strategy, method and objectives of ARVP were presented in more detail. After the final two day meetings they were normally left
with about 2-3 leaders who were then invited for monthly training, which is vigorous, hard and focused on achieving their aim.

Says Mohan: “We are building a new movement completely alien to the existing political culture and we have implemented a detailed and difficult process to develop
leaders based on building relationships, hard work and a commitment to serve. Our goal was to find 200 such leaders by the end of 2010 to start the process of rigorous training. We will probably see a serious attrition of more than 50%. We currently have 160 such leaders and from this beginning, the enforcement of our strategy has commenced. We expect that by the end of 2011 we will be left with 60-80 serious and committed leaders who will be able to pursue our vision in the medium and long term.”

Mohan is aware that any corruption of the people in relation to the vision, methods and underlying ethos which gives priority to relationships, hard work and a commitment to serve, will have disastrous consequences in the short and long term.

I have various questions about the ARVP, and am investigating them to find out more. I hope that you will also want to at least find out about this first ray of political hope for our country.

Any information, evaluations or opinions that you can give me about ARVP will be very welcome.


(The post above is a version of my column, Guptara Garmagaram, titled :"Trees, Jackals, Parasites, Window Watchers: Four kinds of Indians, and a new kind of politics", published in the latest issue of The International Indian magazine, published from Dubai: www.theinternationalindian.com)

Wednesday, 9 February 2011

Should we have more Sachar-type Committees?

Of course. Why not? We could have one for each caste. Then each sub-caste. Then each tribal group. Then each professional group. Then women. Oh, let's not forget the men, which is easy to do nowadays. Oh and then of course hijras. And so on.

But, really, do let's be sensible.

For my invited blog on the subject, please see: http://www.southasianconcern.org/news_and_blog

Thursday, 3 February 2011

Guptara Garamagaram

The above is the title for a column I write regularly in THE INTERNATIONAL INDIAN magazine, which is published every two months from Dubai.

The last column, examining the question: "Why does the average Indian do so well in the USA but not so well in India?" is on page 82 at: http://tinyurl.com/47xgnuo

Sunday, 30 January 2011

Whose responsibility?

At the CII Conference on 'Big Society' in November 2010, some delegates said India had little need for CSR (Corporate & Social Responsibility) managers because it was every worker's responsibility.

This is both true and false.

Of course India is not merely every worker's responsibility, it is everyone's responsibility whether employed or unemployed. That is what it means to be a democracy.

But, where corporations have the status of legal persons, and are accorded more privileges than most real persons, to argue that CSR is not needed is a silly way of trying to evade corporate responsibilities.

Individuals have to take responsibility and are not taking sufficient responsibility. That is why our politics is in such a mess.

Corporations too have to take responsibility, and they are taking nowhere near sufficient responsibility. If they did, our society and economics would be in much better shape.

Thursday, 27 January 2011

The choice between coal and elephants

I have today received the following message from Preethi Herman, the Climate Campaigner for Greenpeace India.

Naturally, it is biased - as all viewpoints are biased.

Please read the following, and then judge for yourself which side you are on:

"The dangerous forest versus coal tussle has claimed its first victim – the endangered Indian elephant. The Chhattisgarh government has scrapped plans for an elephant reserve in order to allow the same forests to be mined for coal. [1]

"Last year the environment and forest ministry defined regions rich in forest cover and biodiversity as No-Go areas for mining. [2] The coal ministry wants the government to scrap this classification. [3] A Group of Ministers (GoM) constituted to resolve this will take a decision later in the year. [4]

"These No-Go areas are among the last remaining forests in our country. They are home to wildlife such as tigers, leopards and elephants, and crucial to the livelihoods of millions. [5] If mining is allowed here, we can bid good bye to all of these. We need to pick our sides for this epic match. Big ministries backed by private lobbies are siding with coal – and against the forests.

"Can you show your support for the elephants and our forests?

http://www.greenpeace.org/india/en/What-We-Do/Stop-Climate-Change/Quit-Coal/support-the-forests/


"This is the first preparatory step for our massive fight to save our forests and the communities who depend on them. The government needs to know that millions of Indians want their forests protected and declared No-Go for mining.

"Instead of increasing its dependence on coal the government needs to invest in exploring renewable energy options. [6] Once destroyed, these forests will never get resurrected even with the best reforestation efforts.

"Clearing forests will only hasten climate change. Coal mining not only destroys forests and displaces communities but also contaminates nearby rivers and water sources.[7] India's remaining forests and wildlife and communities must be protected from mining.

"Show your support for the elephants and their forests now.

http://www.greenpeace.org/india/en/What-We-Do/Stop-Climate-Change/Quit-Coal/support-the-forests/

"Thanks a billion!"

Tuesday, 18 January 2011

Different procedures at different Indian airports

At Bhubaneshwar, they screen for boarding passes twice for some reason! After that, you have to screen your luggage BEFORE you can proceed to Check In (reversing the usual order).

This does make sense from a security point of view, but it is explained nowhere in writing or verbally, resulting in much confusion right at the entry to the airport.

Further, there is no system for removing luggage torlleys once luggage has been checked in, resulting in a log jam of trolleys immediately in front of the Check In desks

At the Check In desks, the signboard in front of one of the two relevant desks said "Delhi" but it was actually checking only passengers for Hyderabad as that flight was first! So Delhi ppassengers kept joining that queue and then, when discovering their "mistake", kept wanting to jump into the middle of the other desk's queue, which was processing Delhi Check Ins!

After Check In, when one tries to clear another round of security in order to get through to the Gate, there was further confusion quite unnecessarily:

In fact, there is probably totally unnecessary confusion there every morning, as late paasengers for Mumbai and then Hyderabad have to be speed processed while passengers who turn up on time for the Delhi flight have to wait in a separate line - but there is no system to indicate that, so the poor security staff and stewards have to shout, and repeat the same information over and over again, to get the non-system to work.

One would have thought that while the police and security staff rotate (at least, one hopes so, for security reasons!), the airline stewards work there regularly, so would have an interest in helping to create a system for their own comfort and health if not for the convenience of passengers, but for some reason, even the stewards seem to be content with or resigned to the non-system.

I wonder why?

I did not ask anyone but, in my experience, whenver such a question is raised, one is met with looks of blank incomprehension - even such simple questions seem impossibly huge.